My Springfield Armory 1911 Micro Compact won't work for me

[stngray713]

I heard and idea somewhere that I thought was interesting may help for those not yet comfortable in condition one. I am not real sure of the particulars of doing it but you could carry a blank in the chamber. That way you don't have to rack the slide if you need to draw because you won't be able to. If you do have a negligent discharge you should be OK asides from ringing ears. Carrying a blank could also work for the folks that insist on firing a warning shot so at least there isn't a stray round flying towards innocents and may stop the attack without really firing a round.

This is not an option I would use because I feel a pistol without a round in the chamber is worthless and I wouldn't fire a warning shot but this may suite someones needs. I'd love to know what y'all think.

[Deanimator]

I heard and idea somewhere that I thought was interesting may help for those not yet comfortable in condition one. I am not real sure of the particulars of doing it but you could carry a blank in the chamber. That way you don't have to rack the slide if you need to draw because you won't be able to. If you do have a negligent discharge you should be OK asides from ringing ears. Carrying a blank could also work for the folks that insist on firing a warning shot so at least there isn't a stray round flying towards innocents and may stop the attack without really firing a round.

This is not an option I would use because I feel a pistol without a round in the chamber is worthless and I wouldn't fire a warning shot but this may suite someones needs. I'd love to know what y'all think.

Among the MULTITIDE of reasons why this is a bad idea is the fact that most locked breach semi-auto handguns will not FUNCTION reliably with blanks without some form of modification that makes them unusable with live ammunition. On movie sets, this usually amounts to a barrel with a restricted bore to produce enough chamber pressure to cycle the action. Such barrels can be constructed to preclude the use of live ammunition. Either way, subsequent use of a live round would be HIGHLY dangerous to the shooter.

So, what are you going to do?

Shoot a blank round, cycle the action and shoot a live one?
Shoot a blank round, field strip the gun and replace the barrel, then shoot a live round?

That of course leaves aside the stupidity of "warning shots", which goes without saying.

It's a foolish "solution" to an unfounded fear about an imaginary "problem".

[Providence Ranch]

Go Glock. And like G50AE said, don't look back. Leave the 1911s for people who want plenty of practice with malfunction drills.

[stngray713]

I completely agree that it is not a solution I would even think about. I was not aware the need to modify the gun to use a blank that is why I said I wasn't sure of the particulars. Although I thought Brandon Lee died because someone put live ammo in the pistol and fired it at him thinking it was blanks but I could be wrong.

I agree warning shots are dumb as well but for those that insist on using them and won't change their mind I figured this was better than sending a round downrange. I carry condition one and always have I never even thought about not having one in the chamber but again some people refuse to and again rather than trying to change their mind which has been tried to no avail so I tried to offer an alternative. I guess the alternative won't help but I thought it was an interesting idea if there was not modifications required and the action could still cycle.

[agrippakc]

You'd carry a glock condition 1 but not a 1911? There are 3 safeties counting tge trigger that all have to be in the correct position to fire. The glock has one. Remember the police officer that shot himself in the class room with the neglegent discharge? I don't care for a lot of the newer designs for the same reason.

[Timothy2001]

I very much appreciate all of the input and feedback. I am going to get more comfortable with the 1911 and carry that instead of buying a glock.

[Iam2Taz]

I can't believe you're seriously suggesting that a Glock is more safe than an SA 1911. Your 1911 has a grip safety, a thumb safety, and by virtue of being in a rigid holster like a CB supertuck, a booger-picker safety. Three safeties. It won't go off by itself even if dropped. Many people swear by Glock, but your comfort level about carrying condition one is NOT going to be allayed by switching to, what is basically a striker fired single action with no external safety. Glocks have short consistent trigger pulls with a finger safety that can be foiled by excess clothing material like a shirt tail or even the seat belt of your vehicle. My suggestion then would be to carry condition 3 until you feel comfortable with your gun handling. In the interim, practice drawing with no rounds in the gun, but in C1 state in front of a mirror. Practice disengaging, and reengaging the safety as you draw and holster the weapon. Join a club like IDPA where you get scenario based practice drawing from concealment. I didn't immediately carry condition 1 either, but I never considered switching to Glock as a fix.

THIS! ^^^ But go ahead and get the Glock. PM me and send the 1911 to me. ;-)

[NCIC105]

Both 1911 and Glock's are good weapon systems....The key is to know your weapon and practice - practice - practice.

Get a good holster and run drills on safely with drawing the weapon from the holster and unloading your weapon.

My kids (now adult) like the Glock's. I carried one for years and own one...I took them outside and made them practice jacking a round in and out as well as the proper way to draw it from the holster....OVER & OVER AGAIN... Until (not them) I felt comfortable with their performance..

I now cross carry (not to be confused with "Cross Dressing") the Glock, 40 cal or my 1911 Warthog, 45 cal... The Warthog has less recoil. When I carry either weapon then have a live round in the pipe...

[wizard]

A Glock is a DAO stiker fired weapon with 3 safeties, a tigger safety and a firing pin block which is disengaged only as the weapon is fully cocked. Most 1911's have 3 safeties, A manual thumb safety, a grip safety and firing pin block. There seems to be some confusion by some people on these particular issues. Both are very safe weapons when used and handled properly. I shoot and carry both. In reply to the OP, carry whatever works best for you. I feel that the SA Micro is a good choice, but you need to train and feel confident with what you are going to carry.