I must respectfully disagree. The burglars put this man in a very unenviable position where he had to defend himself and his family with deadly force. In my mind they should be charged with her death. Had they not broken into the house (a criminal act) this would not have happened. I agree that Mr. Burton made a huge mistake in closing his eyes before he shot but I really cannot judge the actions of a man who is in a position I have never been in. In my opinion he made the mistake so he is responsible but should not be held criminally responsibe. Besides, who do we want off the streets - two thugs who broke into a house or a man who tried to defend his family and made a grave mistake?
I have actually heard of a training doctrine for night firing where you close your eyes right as you fire the weapon and open them right afterwards - it's kind of like blinking in time with the shots.
| | ![]() |
Yes SC Tiger, you're correct that none of that would have happened if the burglars hadn't broken in, but the fact remains that they didn't shoot anybody; the father did, and he did it with his eyes closed. The fact that they're being charged for a murder they didn't commit is ridiculous.
tattedupbay, the hand of one is the hand of all. This incident wouldn't of happened if the BG's had not violated the Law. Anything after that initial violation is chargeable. If the guys wife would have had a heart attack and died, they'd be charged with manslaughter. Their criminal act intiaited a string of events. ALL events are from their choice. ON THE OTHER SIDE think of it this way. If initial evidence is secured agaisnt someone that was not legally obtained, ALL other evidence collected afterward is thrown out (As it should). So the link, chain if you will, goes both ways.
Just my opinion, not telling anybody how to think or what to do.
"The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities." --author and philosopher Ayn Rand (1905-1982)
Screams break the silence
Waking from the dead of night
Vengeance is boiling
He's returned to kill the light
Then when he's found who he's looking for
Listen in awe and you'll hear him
Bark at the moon
Years spent in torment
Buried in a nameless grave
Now he has risen
Miracles would have to save
Those that the beast is looking for
Listen in awe and you'll hear him
Bark at the moon
They cursed and buried him
Along with shame
And thought his timeless soul had gone
In empty burning Hell-unholy one
But now he's returned to prove them wrong
Howling in shadows
Living in a lunar spell
He finds his heaven
Spewing from the mouth of hell
And when he finds who he's looking for
Listen in awe and you'll hear him Bark at the moon
But the little girl's death was a direct result of the burglars' breaking into the house with possible malicious intent (an illegal act). As mappow put it, had the father had a heart attack as a result of this then they would have been charged with murder as well. Once you commit a criminal act, you are responsible for all of the consequences.
If you can't live with that, don't break in people's houses.
Watched this video on TV. Two guys come into store. BG one jumps the counter and gets shot by clerk, jumps back over counter, runs outside and dies. BG two, fires off a couple of rounds at the clerk (missed) and runs out after his buddy.
BG one is dead. BG two is caught by police. BG two is charged with the death of BG one. Justice served.