Another SC Home Defense Shooting - Page 2
Page 2 of 21 FirstFirst 123412 ... LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 208

Thread: Another SC Home Defense Shooting

  1. #11
    I basically agree with the homeowner's actions BUT I wonder how the discussion in the AG office must have been like.

    From SC Law Enforcement Webpages and my CCW course manual

    Defense of Property
    “…in the protection of one’s dwelling, only such force must be used as is necessary, or apparently necessary, to a reasonably prudent man. Any greater expenditure cannot be justifiable and is therefore punishable. State v. Hibler, 79 S.C. 170, 60 S.E. 438 (1907).

    “[t]he weight of modern authority limits deadly force in a defense of a dwelling to situations in which the householder reasonably believes that the intruder intends to commit a felony or only when deadly force would be authorized by the law of self-defense.” McAninch and Fairey.

    In South Carolina the requirements for defense of property is essentially the same as defense of self, EXCEPT that deaqdly force may not be used for defense of property alone An owner cannot shoot a thief - before, after or during a theft. The same rule prohibits use of deadly force to pevent injury or vandalism to property.

    So I feel the owner MAY be on thin ice just because the thief would not comply fast enough for the owner. I was taught we don't have police powers so ordering anyone to comply especially after we have them basically "covered" is IMO shaky...

    Key Words are "I felt in danger of my life" --- repeat over and over and over "That's my story and I'm sticking with it until my lawyer arrives".

  2.   
  3. People I know don't walk around with their hands in their pockets unless they're putting something into them or pulling something out. Someone who hesitates and brings one hand out of their pocket, then waits to bring the other out seems potentially threatening to me.

    Only the guy involved knows what was going through his mind, and if he felt that the bad guy was about to draw a weapon then it is what it is: a fully justified shooting and in compliance with the law.

  4. #13
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    South Carolina/Charleston
    Posts
    2,388
    Hey Booga: I still find it hard to just dismiss the old man who did not first call 911. He finally called after he shot the 19 year old. Personally I do not want to be nor do I consider myself to be Rambo and Dirty Harry; stealing stuff out of a truck and even a house that is insured will get me new and better stuff--confronting the perp may get me killed or put me in a situation where I may have to kill and then explain my actions. To each his own and I respect more forceful decisions, but I will only confront and, if I am in the process of doing so will kill, only if my life and that of my family is jeopardized. I have a locked bedroom door and if someone is rummaging around in my house there is nothing worth anything that is not insured--I will call 911 and wait( having children in other rooms is another story). If they so much as sniff at my locked door and begin to open it they will die.Lets hope that all of us who read and write into this forum can always talk about this and never have to experience any of it.

  5. #14
    Quote Originally Posted by kelcarry View Post
    Hey Booga: I still find it hard to just dismiss the old man who did not first call 911. He finally called after he shot the 19 year old. Personally I do not want to be nor do I consider myself to be Rambo and Dirty Harry; stealing stuff out of a truck and even a house that is insured will get me new and better stuff--confronting the perp may get me killed or put me in a situation where I may have to kill and then explain my actions. To each his own and I respect more forceful decisions, but I will only confront and, if I am in the process of doing so will kill, only if my life and that of my family is jeopardized. I have a locked bedroom door and if someone is rummaging around in my house there is nothing worth anything that is not insured--I will call 911 and wait( having children in other rooms is another story). If they so much as sniff at my locked door and begin to open it they will die.Lets hope that all of us who read and write into this forum can always talk about this and never have to experience any of it.
    While you mean well and I agree with you, I for one do not have any kind of insurance that would cover me. This is not to say that monetary value establishes the need to kill someone over theft, but as stated in somebodies earlier post, somebody taking away something that was earned by spending precious moments of your life is irreplaceable.

    That being said, I respect the decision the guy made, even though I may or may not have done the same thing.
    Gun control: Forcing a 95lb woman to fist fight a 300lb rapist

  6. #15
    Having been burlarized several times in my (long) life, I can tell you it pisses me off to no end. And basically, I have no problem with thieves knowing they could be shot for their trouble. However...I have raised two sons and think I would have a problem planting 2 in some 19-year olds thorasic cavity, for stealing **** out of my truck. I could see knocking his head off with a well-placed crack to the noggin, but shooting him...I don't know. Of course, if I think he's pulling a weapon or something, all bets are off. I do spend considerable time musing over "shoot, no-shoot" scenarios (as I was trained to do) and I gotta tell ya, it's problematic. If it's a clearly life-threatening situation, ok, but anything less than that, I got my doubts as to whether I could. Maybe I'm just a big *****.

  7. #16
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    South Carolina/Charleston
    Posts
    2,388
    Hey JJFlash: I appreciated your comments and NO you are not a *****. With all due respects and apologies to forum writers who are willing to end a life over some silverware, or a computer, or a spare tire in the back of a truck, I really believe that your comments come a lot easier when you are sitting at your computer and replying to these threads. I would think that if you truly mean what you say, your "real out" (after calling 911) is to put yourself in jeopardy first by confronting the perp in the dark of night and not knowing whether he is a dopehead who will shoot you in an instant. Under that circumstance and unless you are prepared to die first, you can then "investigate" what is going on and immediately "fear for your life" and use your weapon. There are some terrible choices to make over some "stuff". Having said the above, I have nothing but compassion and support for any of you who are willing to take the gamble and see to it that some lowlife does not take advantage of you and your property.

  8. #17
    Appreciate that, Kelcarry.

    Another point: Some have wondered what to do if you're holding someone for the cops and they get up and run away. Shoot him in the back?!! I don't think so. To me, it begs the question: what are you doing pointing a gun at someone and holding him for the cops? WE'RE NOT COPS. My gun comes out only if I intend to use it. I don't know of any CCW laws which permit us to hold someone at gunpoint. And how the hell could you justify shooting someone in the back? You gotta know you'd be prosecuted for this; where was the "fear for my life" factor? I suppose we could handcuff someone, but if you're interested in doing that, you might as well be a cop.

    I'm trying to imagine an instance where I've yanked my weapon, pointed it at someone, and demanded that they freeze while I call the cops. And I can't. If a BG has a weapon out and is threatening someone, then just shoot 'em. Damned if I'm gonna play cop, it's good way to end up dead. So, the only scenario I can imagine is property theft. And I'm already on record as saying I doubt I'm gonna shoot someone for stealing something. Just me. Not trying to piss of any of my gun-toting brothers.

  9. #18
    The key in this case was how the robber taking his hands out of his pocket. As stated earlier if he starts to run what are you going to do? But to stop the robbery by going out and point a gun is fine to me. If I hear something outside I am going to investigate. I don't want to be calling 911 over the squirrels jumping on my window screen. I am going outside to investigate while armed. If a 19 year old has his head stuck inside my car he is goint to have a gun pointed at him. If he makes sudden moves like he is going to attack me he is going to be shot. If he just behaves and then runs the police are going to handle it. Either way I am not going to stay in my house and watch him through the window steal whatever he wants while I am on the phone with 911.

  10. #19
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    The High Country
    Posts
    1,029
    When seconds count, the police are only minutes away. Now, if we only had enough laws to cover every imaginable scenario in between, we wouldn't be having this discussion. And nobody would ever need a firearm for protection (of self, property, whatever). And then I woke up...

  11. #20
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    South Carolina/Charleston
    Posts
    2,388
    Hey FN1910: All the more power to you if you are so confident with your use of your firearm in the middle of the night as you confront someone who obviously is up to no good and who may have you outgunned and outexperienced. As I have always said in these posts--to each his own. I know I can shoot straight and accurate enought to hit what I aim at and certainly with a 12g (also have a 38) have the firepower to meet the perp but, for me, insurance will reimburse me and I do not have to put myself in the position of "him or me"and even worse "just me"--all over "stuff". Lets all hope that we can talk this talk on this thread a lot and never have to walk the walk in the middle of the night.I sure respect your decision FN1910 and would be one of those who would pat you on the back with an "attaboy" but it just isn't in my "what if". In my house is a whole different story--the scenario becomes very clear--you are in my house with nothing but bad intentions and are trying to open a locked bedroom door and I AM SCARED and I AM FEARFUL for my wife and myself--unless he hightails it out the door when I rack the 12g, he will die.

Page 2 of 21 FirstFirst 123412 ... LastLast

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Quantcast