FNH 5.8 Semi Auto - Page 2
Page 2 of 5 FirstFirst 1234 ... LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 46

Thread: FNH 5.8 Semi Auto

  1. Quote Originally Posted by Glock Fan View Post
    I found the FN 5.7 to be over rated. Ammo cost is high
    FN ammo can be had for $20 a box of 50rds, and is useable for hunting or self defense, not just plinking.

    Seems rather cheap to me, honestly.

    Quote Originally Posted by Glock Fan View Post
    performance in various mediums questionable.
    Depends on the load. Top Elite and FN SS192/198 loads are extremely effective barrier penetrators, will blow right through soft body armor, and yet still blow through 12+" of bare gel.

    Quote Originally Posted by Glock Fan View Post
    Recoil seemed to be similar to a .40 S&W, however performance was comparable to a .22 mag.
    I must question if you even fired a Five SeveN at all. Recoil is more like a .22 mag than a .40 S&W. The Five SeveN, even with the hottest loads, has very little recoil at all.

    As far as terminal effects, Brassfetcher labs gel tested the Elite S4 round and stated as follows in the summarized report:

    "As tested, both 5.7x28mm cartridges (Elite S4M and Elite Protector II) offer lethality that is on par or slightly greater then a .45 ACP 230gr Jacketed Hollowpoint. (Round shown was the Federal 230gr Hydrashok JHP)."

    It further states:

    "Conversely, the FN SS192/5 and Elite ammunition S4M offer performance quite similar to the tested .45 ACP, with considerably lower recoil and ammunition weight, coupled with a significantly higher magazine capacity.
    We feel that the S4M can be viewed as a "+P" version of very effective SS192/95 27.5gr, and we have no qualms about recommending this cartridge as a feasible replacement to the more conventional .45 ACP handgun, for use against human attackers."

    http://www.eliteammunition.net/f/Eli...Performance_Su mmary.pdf

    Here is video of an S4 gel test:

    1&feature=iv

    Seriously, you are making completely unsupportable claims in your post.

  2.   
  3. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by jathtech View Post
    hahaha... people love my ballistic busts!

    Sorry, I borrowed them to make a point(hope you understand) ;)

  4. #13
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Central Florida
    Posts
    2,004
    Quote Originally Posted by kelcarry View Post
    Friend and I are interested in the FNH 5.8. All comments I have seen make it out to be one of the best semi autos out there and certainly very lethal.Also like the idea that it uses a 20 round mag, which puts it into a very effective capacity category. Only concerns we both have is how it "feels" in your hand (large and small (posssibly for wife) and its recoil. We have not found any shops that have this firearm as a rental and we feel it is improper to ask to use same in a shop and then think about purchasing internet---the price difference is at leat $200 and that is a bit of money. Anyone have one of these and how does it compare say to a 38 revolver or a semi auto in the 9mm to 45 size?
    You meant the FN 5.7 right? I haven't been able to find one listed as the FN5.8 although BlackHawk! Does list a Serpa for the "5.8"

  5. #14
    I believe that side by side, I'd take the Kel-Tec PMR-30.
    War to the Knife, Knife to the hilt.
    If we don't want to live in a trashy area, we all have to be willing to help pick up the trash.

  6. #15
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    South Carolina/Charleston
    Posts
    2,388
    Hey fudo: Just read your comment on preferred KT PMR-30. When you read up on the KT, they describe it as "good for target shooting and small game". Yes it has a 30 round capacity and it is a heck of a lot cheaper than the FN5.7 but what makes you so sure, in your opinion, that they are equivalent or that the 30 is better? Have you actually shot the FN or actually compared it on the range to the PMR30? I believe, just based on overall reviews that FN and KT are on different quality/construction/operational levels. I never see a description of an FN5.7 that says it is good for small game--the usual words and reviews on the 5.7 are it is very good, reliable, and well made at short and long distances. I would love to save money and get max bang/buck and I would appreciate any further comments you may have about the KT PMR30 that can convince me that it is the equivalent of an FN5.7. I do not own one but am considering having something that has high capacity and intend it for basically home defense at distances within 20 yards where a hit or multiple hits will end any problems immediately. I do have an HD shotgun with 18 inch barrel and want to supplement it with an easy to handle high capacity handgun to replace my 38, which is extremely reliable like most revolvers are, but will give me capacity that will guarantee me many accurate good final shots if, g-d forbid, it is necessary, particularly, IMO, in the current "climate of change" our vaunted king with no clothes is taking us to.

    PS: After I wrote the above, I checked comments on the PMR30 and KT now has a recall going for problems. Many comments talk about "failures to fire". All you need is one misfire--30 cartridges will mean nothing then. Confidence, if this is "the firearm to have" does not seem to be in the same ballpark with my shotgun, my 38 or what I read about the FN5.7. Your comments on all of what I have written would be most welcome. The idea of spending $1000, even if it shoots all the time, seems a bit high if there are others out there that will not misfire, which is giving me some cause for concern with the PMR30.

  7. #16
    I would choose the KT over the FN for several reasons. The KT is roughly $400, as opposed to roughly $1000. Ammunition for the KT is vastly cheaper and more readily available than the 5.7. The KT small parts are also cheaper, and they are simple to work on.
    I have handled both guns, but not shot either one. I think that the FN is the better weapon, especially if the military and police rounds are available, but 2 1/2 times better? And twice as expensive to shoot? My answer is no, your priorities may be different.
    War to the Knife, Knife to the hilt.
    If we don't want to live in a trashy area, we all have to be willing to help pick up the trash.

  8. #17
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    South Carolina/Charleston
    Posts
    2,388
    Hey fudo: There is one major priority that we both can agree on--will the firearm fire when I want it to and will it continue to fire if I need it to. That, to me, and I cannot believe that you disagree, is priority one. Without that happening, I might as well have a rock in my hand. I agree with you on price and I agree with you that if it functions 100%, the KT can defend my home under the constraints that I am willing to live with (I have no interest in knowing that I can hit a bullseye at 50-100 yards without bullet decline and have no interest in knowing that I can penetrate body armor at 10 yards or greater). I am in my house, someone is crawling around, I am fearing for my life and I want capacity, and multiple shots so I can assure myself that I will hit the perp and hurt him, and a feeling that the firearm will bring this nightmare to a conclusion. I also want to be proficient with its use without going broke over hundreds of rounds of practice ammunition. BUT WILL IT WORK WHEN I NEED IT TO? I surely hope that KT can supply me with the kind of confidence I need in this product. Maybe their latest problems will solve all their problems. PS: I own a KT P3AT that has never caused me a bit of problem over countless hundreds of rounds of practice.
    Thanks for your replies and sounding board for my concerns.

  9. Quote Originally Posted by fudo View Post
    I believe that side by side, I'd take the Kel-Tec PMR-30.
    For defense?

    This is a direct apple to apple comparison:

    Kel Tec PMR-30, advertised velocity with Winchester 40gr HP: 1230fps, 134 ft-lbs energy.

    FN Five SeveN, advertised velocity with Elite 40gr V-max Ballistic tip JHP: 2090fps, 390 ft-lbs energy.

    So let's see....the Five Seven has about 70-80% more velocity, a far superior streamlined spitzer type V-max bullet, and just shy of TRIPLE the muzzle energy. On top of that, the Five SeveN uses extremely reliable rimless center fire ammunition, whereas the PMR-30 uses less reliable rimmed rimfire ammuniton.

    These two pistols are not even remotely comparable as defensive tools. The PMR-30 is a neat-o range or plinking toy. The FN FsN is a 21st century war fighting tool capable of defeating even Class IIIA body armor with any of a variety of civilian legal rounds.

    I have personally shot FN SS192 through 48 layers of Kevlar in tests. That is the rough equivalent to shooting through both sides of a Level IIIA vest.

    How much does a box of 50rds of premium .22 magnum hunting ammunition cost? Because i can get a box of 50rds of premium FN SS197SR 40gr Vmax for $20 bucks online.

    BTW, i do own an FN Five SeveN USG model. I have owned numerous top end high quality firearms (HK's, Sigs, Berettas, Colts, you name it), and IMO, the Five SeveN firing hot Elite ammo is in a league of it's own with regard to it's combat effectiveness.
    I am Infantry, follow me!

  10. #19
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    South Carolina/Charleston
    Posts
    2,388
    Hey Valorius: Appreciate your comments backed up by facts and figures. Looking at the "standard" 5.7 cartridge, I had reservations about what exactly it could do from a HD/SD standpoint. Looking at your comments re Elite and following up with due diligence, it becomes evident that Elite has a package that is extremely potent for HD/SD. What really intrigued me about the 5.7 is the low recoil vs its lethality with high capacity that IMO cannot be matched with any other handgun out there. It was the last 2 factors that had me think about the PMR30 but it just seems no matter how you try to convince yourself, a 22mag is still a 22 and the PMR's reliability on every shot seems to be an issue that will never go away given rimfire design. Are there any other handguns out there that have elements of all three of my priorities (low recoil, lethality and high capacity) with reliability (a must for SD/HD) or does this come down to the "you get what you pay for". PS: I intend to use such a handgun for SD/HD (not CC but in the home--I know I will not CC a big gun--I have a small 380, which I do CC) at less than 10 yards. I cannot envision, given my lifestyle and abilities, for its use at anything more than that. Given that limitation as probably a 100% certainty, which sights are more in line with my thinking? My answer at this point are the fixed tactical and not the adjustable. Do you agree? I really want to thank you for your comments--they have been very helpful. Cudos to Randy, as well. Thanks guys. This is what this forum is all about.

  11. Besides the FN FsN (abbreviation for the Five SeveN), there are only 2 other PDW chambered pistols that i am aware of.

    One is the cancelled HK UCP (Ultimate Combat Pistol), chambered for 4.6x30mm.

    The other is the Chinese Army's 5.8mm DAP 92 pistol.

    Obviously, neither one is available, so the FN FsN is literally the only pistol on earth that can do what it can do.

    The FN ammo is much weaker than the Elite stuff, however, at Fort Hood, the terrorist used FN SS192 ammo (28gr OTM @ 2100fps) to great effect, achieving 4 separate instant stops against 2 US troops (both attacked him at close range with chairs/tables when the terrorist first opened fire), a US cop (Ofc Munley), and an orderly.

    Elite loads the same bullet that the SS192 uses, but to a much higher velocity.

    Here is the dirt on the 28gr OTM loadings. All velocities listed for FsN pistol, and all rounds use the same 27.5gr aluminum core jacketed OTM design. I posted a link to gel tests for it in one of my previous posts in this thread.

    FN SS192: 2100fps
    FN SS195 white box: 2100fps
    FN SS195LF blue box: 1900fps (watered down post Fort Hood ammo)
    FN SS198 LE/Mil only: 2200fps
    Elite S4M: 2600fps

    The only other FN round is the SS197SR sporting round, a 40gr Vmax at about 1700fps
    Elite loads the same 40gr Vmax to almost 2100fps.

    Elite also loads several other very hot "+P" offerings in 5.7mm as well.

    Glad i could help. Buy a Five SeveN, you won't regret it.
    I am Infantry, follow me!

Page 2 of 5 FirstFirst 1234 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Quantcast