Latest Developments in Martinsburg City Building Gun Ban Lawsuit

Latest Developments in Martinsburg City Building Gun Ban Lawsuit
Latest Developments in Martinsburg City Building Gun Ban Lawsuit
Latest Developments in Martinsburg City Building Gun Ban Lawsuit
Latest Developments in Martinsburg City Building Gun Ban Lawsuit

On September 6, the defendants in WVCDL’s lawsuit against the City of Martinsburg filed an answer to WVCDL’s amended complaint.  Unfortunately, just a few hours later, the court issued an Order of Abstention (the order was amended a week later to correct a clerical error), directing WVCDL to file a separate lawsuit in state court to litigate the questions of state law separately from the federal case and return to federal court if we fail to overturn the city building gun ban ordinance in the separate case.

In its Order of Abstention, the Court exhibited a breathtaking disregard for the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1997 decision in Arizonans for Official English v. Arizona, in which the Supreme Court clearly directed the federal courts to send certified questions of law to a state supreme court instead of forcing the parties to engage in redundant litigation in state court in most cases.  Following this decision, the 4th Circuit (which includes West Virginia) and 7 other circuits decided cases in which they followed the Supreme Court’s ruling in the Arizona case.

In response to WVCDL’s arguments that the Arizona case required the court to not abstain and instead certify questions of law to the West Virginia Supreme Court, the court cited two cases where other courts had abstained due to the same legal issues being litigated in separate lawsuits already pending in the state court system.  There are no parallel cases present in West Virginia. One of these cases comes from a circuit that is not fully complying with the Supreme Court’s direction in the Arizona case, which cannot be followed here because our circuit has taken a different view.  The second case comes from a circuit that has certified questions in other cases where there is not already a parallel lawsuit pending in state court. The court then cited a third case, a 25-year-old New York case that has never been cited by any other court, to argue that the slightest possibility of any factual dispute requires the case to be sent to state court.

In response to the court’s Order of Abstention, WVCDL has filed motions to seek reconsideration of the Order of Abstention, certify questions of law to the West Virginia Supreme Court, strike certain frivolous defenses from the Defendants’ answer, issue a preliminary injunction, and grant WVCDL summary judgment on 3 of its 4 state law claims where the facts are already clearly settled.

We do not have a timetable for rulings on these motions.  We hope the court will carefully consider these motions and reverse its Order of Abstention.  If the court denies WVCDL’s motion to reconsider, WVCDL may either file a separate lawsuit in state court or appeal the abstention order to the 4th Circuit.  Either option will likely add nearly a full year to the amount of time that will be required for WVCDL to obtain justice and force the City of Martinsburg to comply with state law, the state constitution, and the U.S. Constitution.  This is precisely the sort of delay the U.S. Supreme Court intended to avoid with its clear guidance in the Arizona case for federal courts to certify questions of law to a state supreme court instead of abstaining in most cases.

$11.99
No Code Needed
J P Enterprises - Ar-15 Reduced Power Spring Kit

J P Enterprises – Ar-15 Reduced Power Spring Kit

Reduced-power springs provide a 3.5 pound trigger pull when used with J.P. triggers, and a pull of 4.5 to 5 pounds when used with standard trigger components.

$189.99
No Code Needed
CMC TRIGGERS - AR-15 TACTICAL BLK TRIGGER SINGLE STAGE 3.5LBS

MCM Triggers – AR-15 Tactical BLK Trigger Single Stage 3.5lbs

This Brownells AR-15 Tactical Black Trigger features a flat trigger bow that enhances leverage and gives shooters more control over their trigger press.

$289.99 (Reg. $379.99)
No Code Needed
Smith & Wesson M&p Shield 9mm

Smith & Wesson M&p Shield 9mm

Smith & Wesson’s new M&P SHIELD™ is a slim, concealable, lightweight, striker-fired polymer pistol.  Available in 9mm, the new M&P SHIELD features a slim design combined with the proven and trusted features found in the M&P Pistol Series. From the pistol’s easily concealed one-inch profile to its optimized 18-degree grip angle, the M&P SHIELD offers professional-grade features that provide consumers with simple operation and reliable performance.

Previous articleCalifornia Governor Has Four Anti-Gun Bills to Consider and Time is Running out to Request His Veto
Next articleExamples of Why You Need to Keep Your Finger Off the Trigger at all Times
The West Virginia Citizens Defense League is a nonpartisan, nonprofit, all-volunteer, grassroots organization of concerned West Virginians who support our individual right to keep and bear arms for defense of self, family, home and state, and for lawful hunting and recreational use, as protected by the state constitution and the Second Amendment of the United States Constitution.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Anonymous

ok

rifle scopes

Criminals will find a way to commit crimes with or without guns. So I think it would not be wise to ban guns at all.