SAN FRANCISCO, CA — San Francisco Sheriff Paul Miyamoto has issued a formal apology following revelations that his office failed to process timely renewal requests for concealed carry weapon (CCW) permits, resulting in some legally issued permits expiring without action.
According to a report by SF Public Safety News, the Sheriff’s Office currently has at least 43 pending applications that have not been renewed or denied, despite being filed on time. Sheriff Miyamoto acknowledged the lapse in a statement, saying, “We have experienced administrative delays in processing renewals and I take full responsibility for the Sheriff’s Office failure to process and renew CCW permits, which resulted in some unintentionally expiring.”
“This should not have happened,” Miyamoto added.
The delays come at a critical time, as the two-year permits issued after the landmark June 2022 U.S. Supreme Court decision New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen are now up for renewal. The Bruen ruling struck down “good cause” requirements for CCW issuance, compelling jurisdictions like San Francisco to begin issuing permits to qualified applicants.
Prior to the Bruen decision, San Francisco officials largely refused to issue CCW permits to law-abiding residents. In response to the ruling, the Sheriff’s Office implemented one of the most stringent permit processes in the state, requiring multiple steps including a psychological evaluation. Since then, 163 permits have been issued by the Sheriff’s Department.
Sheriff Miyamoto attributed the renewal delays to budget-related staffing shortages, stating, “Due to city budget cuts, we are currently operating with only 63% of our normal professional staffing levels. This reduction has had a substantial impact on our ability to process CCW applications and renewals in a timely manner.”
Despite the issue, Miyamoto stressed that his office is not seeking to infringe upon Second Amendment rights. “I want to be clear, we are not attempting to block or limit anyone’s lawful right to carry a firearm.”
Frustrated applicants were reportedly told that delays were due to broader issues with “City Hall.” Meanwhile, the San Francisco Police Department also holds authority to issue CCW permits in the city, but a spokesperson for new SFPD Chief Derrick Lew declined to comment on how the department is handling its own backlog of applications or renewals.
This situation highlights the ongoing tension between city-level policies and constitutional carry rights affirmed by the Supreme Court. While Sheriff Miyamoto’s acknowledgment and apology are a step toward accountability, the lapse underscores the importance of ensuring that bureaucratic challenges do not interfere with law-abiding citizens’ ability to exercise their rights.
Maintaining timely CCW renewals is not merely an administrative task—it is a constitutional obligation. For permit holders who have completed all legal requirements, bureaucratic failures should not be the reason they are stripped of their ability to carry legally.
