The Best SHTF Gun Debate Is…No Debate At All

The Best SHTF Gun Debate Is…No Debate At All

The first time I shot my M&P15 Sport 2, AR 15, I realized exactly what I had. I was in possession of an economical, incredibly powerful and accurate, brand-backed, SHTF gun. And the good news is, that’s exactly why I bought this beast of a weapon. We can discuss specs all day, but that would defeat the point of this article. Because in the end, my purchase of the M&P15 Sport 2 AR 15 was one of economics and usefulness. Those factors might not fill your perceived prepper voids.

So let’s hit some backstory.

I’m a prepper. I’m not sure I’d call myself an elite prepper by any means, I don’t have an expensive homestead, filled with massive food and water storage units, and flanked by a military grade safe house. But I do prepare for the worst. And I do run a prepper news site. I have water filters, fires starters, multiple survival knives and a bug out bag. I have a guide written for how to survive an EMP attack. And yes, it includes having a reliable SHTF gun.

Your Glock Won’t Cut It When SHTF Goes Down

This is one of the biggest questions I get when discussing a SHTF gun: Will my Glock 43 be sufficient? My answer is always, “not really.” In the end, any gun is better than no gun if massive looting and civil unrest become a new reality. I’d rather have 7 close range rounds than no rounds whatsoever. I’d rather be able to take down a threat at 20 feet than not be able to take one down at 2 feet. The logic I’m pontificating here is some sound stuff, I don’t think anyone is going to argue that.

But reality is reality. I love my Glock 43. And you probably love your Glock, or Sig Sauer P250, or M&P Shield. These are great guns. They carry potent 9mm rounds. They are as reliable as any gun on the market, including, yes, revolvers. They are accurate in the short range. And most of all, you can conceal them on your body, or store them in a bug out bag without taking up too much extra room.

That’s all good stuff.

But the inherent problem with SHTF is that it is not the same as an attacker in your apartment parking lot. Civil unrest is chaos. Civil unrest can also become organized militias and the gateway into dystopian conditions.

I love my Glock 43, but if true SHTF conditions occur, my timeline is short if that’s my only firearm. Here’s a couple of short points as to why that is:

  • 9mm rounds aren’t long-range rounds
  • Low magazine capacity

Combine both of those factors and you fall pretty low on the food chain in a civil unrest environment. If someone breaks into your home, the sub-compact handgun certainly has its benefits. If you are walking alone and a knife wielding attacker attempts to harm you, that sub-compact might well be your best friend.

But that’s not civil unrest. Civil unrest could offer multiple attackers acting from points well beyond a sub-compact’s 25 yard max. Now, let’s keep it real for a second. If you have an armed attacker at 25 yards, that’s moving, that’s potentially exchanging rounds with you, you will have 7 rounds to win this battle. Good luck, because being accurate at 25 yards is already tough with pinned paper targets, much less when that target is in motion and exchanging gun fire. Sure, you can swap magazines, but that’s time-consuming and you might not have a ton of time.

The key to surviving such a situation requires longer range accuracy and increased magazine capacity.

The AR 15 Is The Best SHTF Gun There Is

I’ve seen all the debates. And yes, all styles of guns have their pros and cons. But when it comes to a specific SHTF scenario, the AR 15 is not only capable of saving your life but also dramatically increase your survival timeline depending on how prepped you are in every way.

Here’s why:

  • It’s super light
  • It’s ridiculously accurate
  • Its standard magazine holds 30 rounds
  • The rounds (.223) are cheap
  • The round (.223) are readily available (for now, thanks to Trump)
  • It can take down a large animal

The SHTF gun debate is one that gets confused. Handguns, shotguns, and even traditional rifles are all great, but those are truly secondary SHTF guns. Should you have a sub-compact handgun in your bug out bag? Absolutely. Should you sometimes conceal that sub-compact handgun on your body? Of course. The one big flaw with a rifle such as the AR 15 is that your preparedness is out in the open. Additionally, if you stop for water or need to build a homestead, you are probably going to need to lay down your AR 15. Having a subcompact on you is great for the survival business.

Shotguns are the end all when it comes to self-defense and even hunting. They can forgive blemishes in accuracy. But they are heavy, utilize limited ammunition capacity and can destroy the edibility of small prey. They also offer way too much collateral damage potential.

The AR 15 Kills Animals

SHTF is underway. You have some food storage, at least I hope you do. But things happen. And you will need to survive. Wouldn’t it make sense that your gun could also take down a deer if need be? You will need to eat. And an AR 15 offers you an improved chance at bagging a deer over a Glock.

The .223 round is NOT a perfect round to kill a deer with. Nor is it a great round to unload on an angry bear that wants to know why you accidentally walked up on its cubs.

We are talking about versatility here, not perfection.

SHTF is Conspiracy Talk. Right?

No one wants to envision a world that’s so dystopian that we have to hunt deer in order to survive. But to be a prepper, you have to consider a worst-case scenario. North Korea consistently threatens us with an EMP attack. And guess what, they are more than capable of pulling such an attack off. In fact, that would be their logical tactic, all things considered. If the power grid is compromised, get ready, SHTF will be underway in no less than 1 hour. Once the villains figure out that power is gone, they’ll cease the opportunity to move up on the food chain.

I don’t want to spend too much time in this section because if you are so naïve as to believe this is conspiracy talk, you probably shouldn’t be reading this article at all. Recently, St. Martin was subject to a direct hit by superstorm, category 5, Hurricane Irma. And following that, a civil war broke out.

Ask yourself, would you want to rise up from the debris that was once your home and see these circumstances holding only a Glock 43? I think the answer here is obvious.

My Suggestion: M&P15 Sport 2 As SHTF Gun

So of course, I’m saying Smith and Wesson’s entry-level AR 15 is the greatest gun ever manufactured, right? Come on, folks. If you have the money to blow, you can do a lot better than the M&P Sport 2 AR 15. There is no question about it. But remember, we are talking about a SHTF gun. And in such a case, we are likely talking about being economical.

The M&P Sport 2 will run you $700 ON THE HIGH END. It will come with little need for aftermarket parts. It has iron sights, which might be preferable in SHTF conditions. They are deadly accurate.

When you budget for your SHTF gun, you can’t just budget for the cost of the gun. You need to prep and buy monthly ammunition. Rather than purchase a $1500 AR 15, you could get the M&P Sport 2 and tack on $700 in ammunition. That’d be way more effective. That would mean you’d have a deadly accurate AR 15 and near 1,400 rounds. That’s pretty effective prepping.

You can purchase aftermarket parts as you wish. If you want a scope, you can get one after the fact. If you want red dot sights, go for it (but consider buying an emp protective cloth to protect them, like this one on Amazon). The only thing I think is essential to replace is the handguard on the barrel. It is rather terrible. If you fire a full magazine, you will feel a lot of heat and it will stay hot for longer than you’d think. This is due to a lack of metal inside the plastic guard. I think you can get a better Magpul one for $25ish which will also allow you to easily attach accessories that you may add down the road.

The rest of the gun is ready right out of the box. Once you have it, you are just buying ammo and cheap magazines.

This makes is a convenient, economic, AR 15 purchase. But hey, if you have the money to spend on something more robust, I’d say do it. No matter, an AR 15 really needs to be in your prepper, SHTF arsenal. There is no doubt this firearm can sustain your life for years to come, pending you were wise enough to stock up on ammo.

$599.99 (Reg.$ 799.99)
No Code Needed
Sig Sauer P365 9mm Pistol 12 Rd RTT Tacpac, Coyote

Sig Sauer P365 9mm Pistol 12 Rd RTT Tacpac, Coyote

The award-winning P365 has redefined the micro-compact pistol category, quickly becoming one of the most coveted firearms in the industry.

$449.99 (Reg. $549.99)
No Code Needed
Smith & Wesson M&p Shield Ez 9mm Pistol With Manual Safety, Black - 12436

Smith & Wesson M&P Shield EZ 9mm Pistol With Manual Safety, Black

The next evolution of the M&P Shield EZ pistol, the M&P9 Shield EZ encompasses all of the M&P Shield EZ features, now in the powerful 9mm caliber.

No Code Needed
3 Pack Of Blem Psa Stealth Ar-15 Lowers

3 Pack Of BLEM PSA Stealth AR-15 Lowers

These forged lowers are quality made using material is 7075-T6 and are marked "CAL MULTI" to accommodate most builds. The finish is Black Hardcoat Anodize per MIL-8625 Type 3 class 2.

1 2 3 17
Previous articleS&W M360 .357 Airweight Review
Next articleTop 7 Reasons Why You Need An AR Pistol
Cory Wayne is the founder of <a href="" target="_blank", a modern prepper and libertarian news website. Wayne's focus is on fair and balanced reporting as well as spreading awareness regarding the modern prepper movement.
5 1 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I have three ARs, a S&W M&P Sport 2, a Ruger SR-5.56 and a Aero AC-15M. I also own my trusty Mini-14 Ranch. I agree, though. While I have more than mkst, I don’t have more than many. I have several handguns (.22, .380., .38, .357) with 600 rounds per caliber (20,000 .22), several shotguns (two are ‘combat’ shotguns) with 400 rounds of 00, and about 6000 rounds of 5.56. I have enough freeze dried food to feed my family two meals a day for a year, and I can filter 15,000 gallons of water (not to include 3000 gallons of radioactive water), 50 gallons of water in the house at all times, bottles of chlorine, iodine tablets, tarps, lots of duct tape, complete medical kits, solar panels and wind-n-go lighting, communications, gas masks, clean suits, and have fruit trees (cherry, mulberry, plum, pear, Apple, lemon and lime), a supply of seeds to grow veggies, a Farraday cage for electronics, 50 gallons each of gas, kero, jugs of motor oil, generators, a well, a Great Lake out front, medication in shrink bags with moisture and oxygen removers, dehydrated and canned foods, gold, silver and copper ingots, cases of rum, tequila, brandy and vodka, I make my own beer, loads of camping gear including a Biolite Camp Stove and a Biolite Home Stove (awesome things they are!), two buried 1000 gallon propane tanks, 40 small propane camping tanks. I think that’s everything.

Jim L

Preppers R Us.


‘seize’ the opportunity

Great article.


I have to agree with the author on this. Having owned or been issued on Iraq private security contracts everything from Colt and Bushmaster to DPMS and S&W M&P, the M&P is an excellent AR. I love mine and it is my number one go-to gun for almost any purpose. If I need truly long range kill power I use my M1 Garand.


For that I use my .270 Ruger M77 Hawkeye with 130gr. Hornady SST ammo. Fast, flat and furious.

Jim L

.30-06 mauser for over 150-200 yards and 444 Marlin for what’s under that.


SOG Legend Jerry “Mad Dog” Schriver took a Marlin 444 with him to Vietnam to bust bunkers, it was probably the only lever action rifle used in the Vietnam War.

Jim L

I bet it worked well against charlie.

William Ridenour

How did you like your DPMS? I have an AR10 that I like a lot. But I have not gotten theceeal time use that you have. My wife has the 223 S&W M&P and loves the low recoil.


Ok, and where do you carry this monster??? Yeah,I thought so… A SHTF gun needs to be with you when the SHTF. Better a small pocket gun with you ALL OF THE TIME, than worrying about this crap. Waste of space for defense unless you keep it next to your bed…Could ruin a few good nights…


Maybe a zombie apocalypse gun… But I haven’t seen any zombies around…


When it was more common to see a rifle on a kids back than a backpack kidnappings and sex trafficking was very rare and almost unheard of. Kids can be just as responsible as any adult and it tends to be easier for them to do so. The same people trying to hurt our kids are the ones trying to take their rights away so they can’t defend themselves.

Last edited 1 year ago by PatriotsEagleman
Wesley Cristman