USA Carry
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Concealed Carry Maps
  • State Guides
    • A-E
      • Alabama
      • Alaska
      • American Samoa
      • Arizona
      • Arkansas
      • California
      • Colorado
      • Connecticut
      • Delaware
    • F-J
      • Florida
      • Georgia
      • Guam
      • Hawaii
      • Idaho
      • Illinois
      • Indiana
      • Iowa
    • K-M
      • Kansas
      • Kentucky
      • Louisiana
      • Maine
      • Maryland
      • Massachusetts
      • Michigan
      • Minnesota
      • Mississippi
      • Missouri
      • Montana
    • N-O
      • Nebraska
      • Nevada
      • New Hampshire
      • New Jersey
      • New Mexico
      • New York
      • North Carolina
      • North Dakota
      • Northern Marianas
      • Ohio
      • Oklahoma
      • Oregon
    • P-U
      • Pennsylvania
      • Puerto Rico
      • Rhode Island
      • South Carolina
      • South Dakota
      • Tennessee
      • Texas
      • Utah
    • V-Z
      • Vermont
      • Virgin Islands
      • Virginia
      • Washington
      • Washington D.C.
      • West Virginia
      • Wisconsin
      • Wyoming
  • Articles
    • Defensive Gun Uses
    • Concealed Carry
    • Gun Reviews
    • Gear Reviews
    • Training
    • Firearm Laws & Litigation
    • CCW For Women
    • General Firearm
    • Open Carry
    • Self-Defense
    • Survival
    • Home Defense
  • Forums
  • Podcast
  • Store
  • Deals
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Concealed Carry Maps
  • State Guides
    • A-E
      • Alabama
      • Alaska
      • American Samoa
      • Arizona
      • Arkansas
      • California
      • Colorado
      • Connecticut
      • Delaware
    • F-J
      • Florida
      • Georgia
      • Guam
      • Hawaii
      • Idaho
      • Illinois
      • Indiana
      • Iowa
    • K-M
      • Kansas
      • Kentucky
      • Louisiana
      • Maine
      • Maryland
      • Massachusetts
      • Michigan
      • Minnesota
      • Mississippi
      • Missouri
      • Montana
    • N-O
      • Nebraska
      • Nevada
      • New Hampshire
      • New Jersey
      • New Mexico
      • New York
      • North Carolina
      • North Dakota
      • Northern Marianas
      • Ohio
      • Oklahoma
      • Oregon
    • P-U
      • Pennsylvania
      • Puerto Rico
      • Rhode Island
      • South Carolina
      • South Dakota
      • Tennessee
      • Texas
      • Utah
    • V-Z
      • Vermont
      • Virgin Islands
      • Virginia
      • Washington
      • Washington D.C.
      • West Virginia
      • Wisconsin
      • Wyoming
  • Articles
    • Defensive Gun Uses
    • Concealed Carry
    • Gun Reviews
    • Gear Reviews
    • Training
    • Firearm Laws & Litigation
    • CCW For Women
    • General Firearm
    • Open Carry
    • Self-Defense
    • Survival
    • Home Defense
  • Forums
  • Podcast
  • Store
  • Deals
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
USA Carry
No Result
View All Result
  • DAILY GUNS & AMMO DEALS – CLICK HERE!
Home Articles

United States Vs Miller: Second Amendment Court Cases You Should Know

Sam Hoober by Sam Hoober
May 25, 2020
in Articles, General Firearm
Reading Time: 4 mins read
United States Vs Miller: Second Amendment Court Cases You Should Know
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

There are only a few Supreme Court cases involving gun control, and one of the most pertinent is United States vs. Miller of 1939. For those unaware, this court case concerns whether or not the government can regulate what type of firearms you can own.

We all have our opinions or beliefs about this topic. US vs. Miller is one of the few times the Supreme Court has had anything to say about it, which – of course – has the force of law.

This is not to argue for or against the Supreme Court’s decision, the National Firearms Acts, or any type of gun control. For the moment, we’re going to set what you or I or anyone thinks should be to the side. This is about how things are.

United States Vs. Miller: The Background

The background to United States vs Miller starts with the National Firearms Act of 1934. The first NFA was passed in the backdrop of Prohibition (and the Great Depression) when there were almost no firearm regulations; you could literally order a Thompson SMG and have it mailed to you. Saw off a shotgun barrel or shorten a rifle, add a suppressor…no big deal.

But…there was a REAL problem at the time with organized crime. Criminal organizations like the Chicago Outfit (Johnny Torrio’s and later Al Capone’s gang) could afford Thomson SMGs (around $2,000 with inflation) and armored cars, whereas the typical police officer usually had only a .38 Special revolver, and this was in the days before speed loaders.

Not that there wasn’t any firepower in police inventories, but by and large, the national body of law enforcement was under-equipped and under-gunned.

Congress passed the NFA to give law enforcement the edge.

The Case: US Vs. Miller

In 1935, Jack Miller, along with co-plaintiff Frank Layton, were arrested in Arkansas and charged with – among other things – transporting a sawed-off shotgun across state lines without having the proper tax stamp. The case was initially dismissed on the grounds that the NFA’s provisions violated the defendant’s Second Amendment right to bear arms.

Many people, of course, are of the same opinion and will probably say so in the comments; the judge at his trial did likewise. However, the case was appealed by the government and went up the judicial ladder until granted a writ of certiorari and heard by the Supreme Court of the United States in May 1929.

The Decision

The issue before the Supreme Court was considering whether the regulation of the form of a firearm (e.g. a sawed-off shotgun) infringed on the defendants’ Second Amendment rights.

The government contended that the purpose of the Second Amendment was to maintain the ability of the people to be armed for duty in the militia and thus for military purposes.

Since a sawed-off shotgun has little to no military application (as opposed to a combat shotgun) it doesn’t apply, and the court rendered an 8-0-1 decision that it did not, with Justice James McReynolds writing the opinion and Justice William Douglas abstaining.

Justice Reynolds, writing for the court, held:

“In the absence of any evidence tending to show that possession or use of a ‘shotgun having a barrel of less than eighteen inches in length’ at this time has some reasonable relationship to the preservation or efficiency of a well regulated militia, we cannot say that the Second Amendment guarantees the right to keep and bear such an instrument. Certainly it is not within judicial notice that this weapon is any part of the ordinary military equipment or that its use could contribute to the common defense.”

What this means is that firearms considered outside “ordinary military equipment” are, according to the Supreme Court and therefore (unless changed by act of Congress or constitutional amendment) the law of the United States, not necessary for a person to be able to carry and bear arms.

Therefore, there is no right to own or possess one as far as the government is concerned, since it doesn’t fit what the Hughes court felt was the scope and intent of the Second Amendment’s protections.

What happened to Miller, you ask?

Jack Miller was using his sawed-off shotgun to commit a bank robbery and turned state’s evidence (and testified against his co-defendants) when the case got to trial. The shotgun charge was disputed by his and Layton’s attorney on the grounds that the NFA – the means by which he was charged with the crime – was an infringement. Miller was found murdered in April 1939, the month before the case was heard.

What You Think The Second Amendment Means And What SCOTUS Says It Does

This isn’t to say the layperson doesn’t have a valid viewpoint. This is to say that there’s what the layperson thinks the Second Amendment means and what SCOTUS says that it means, the difference, of course, is that SCOTUS decisions have the force of law.

Granted, there’s a good reason for that.

The judiciary branch is supposed to be a bulwark against what James Madison termed the “ill humors in the society,” meaning the transitory and irrational passions of the public; the vox populi (or as William Sherman called it, the vox humbug) is not their guiding star. The judiciary branch was literally designed to NOT be influenced by popular sentiment.

So, what does this court case mean?

It means that, insofar as the current laws and court precedent of the United States are concerned, there CAN be limits on what kind of guns you can own. Since there are clearly some firearms which have no purpose that the Framers even remotely intended for anyone to carry and bear (even by a distant transitive property) there are some firearms that therefore enjoy no Second Amendment protection.

Exactly what those limits are? The court has barely touched on the topic since then. DC vs. Heller found that handguns definitely were, but the court also declined to hear a legal challenge to Maryland’s 2013 assault weapon ban, which could have extended that same protection to semi-auto rifles.

Who knows what future decisions will hold.

Sam Hoober

Sam Hoober

Sam Hoober writes about DGU incidents gun accessories, gun safety, open and concealed carry tips. In his free time, Sam enjoys camping, hunting and spending time at the gun range as often as possible.

Next Post
Concealed Carrier Shoots Pit Bull Attacking His Shepard, No Charges Will Be Filed

Concealed Carrier Shoots Pit Bull Attacking His Shepard, No Charges Will Be Filed

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Connect with
Login
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
Notify of
Connect with
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
Please login to comment
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Previous Post

Homeowner Sees Break-in On Phone App, Confronts Them Through Window, Shoots and Kills One

Next Post

Concealed Carrier Shoots Pit Bull Attacking His Shepard, No Charges Will Be Filed

Related Posts

Armed Good Samaritan Stops Violent Carjacking Spree | Tackles & Detains Suspect at Gunpoint
Articles

Armed Good Samaritan Stops Violent Carjacking Spree | Tackles & Detains Suspect at Gunpoint

June 11, 2025
Concealed Carry Expanded: PA and VA Finalize Firearm Reciprocity Agreement
Articles

Concealed Carry Expanded: PA and VA Finalize Firearm Reciprocity Agreement

June 11, 2025
Articles

“People That Want To Kill You Don’t Care About Your Feelings”

June 10, 2025
Masked Gunman Killed by Employee During Attempted Robbery at Sugar’s Crab Shack
Articles

Masked Gunman Killed by Employee During Attempted Robbery at Sugar’s Crab Shack

June 9, 2025

© 2025 USA Carry LLC

Navigate Site

  • State Guides
  • Maps
  • Articles
  • Forums
  • Podcast
  • Store
  • Deals
  • Giveaway
  • Advertise
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Concealed Carry Permit Reciprocity Maps
  • Concealed Carry Permit Guides By State
    • Alabama
    • Alaska
    • American Samoa
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • California
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Guam
    • Hawaii
    • Idaho
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Kentucky
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Minnesota
    • Mississippi
    • Missouri
    • Montana
    • Nebraska
    • Nevada
    • New Hampshire
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • North Carolina
    • North Dakota
    • Northern Marianas
    • Ohio
    • Oklahoma
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Puerto Rico
    • Rhode Island
    • South Carolina
    • South Dakota
    • Tennessee
    • Texas
    • Utah
    • Vermont
    • Virgin Islands
    • Virginia
    • Washington
    • Washington D.C.
    • West Virginia
    • Wisconsin
    • Wyoming
  • Articles
    • Defensive Gun Uses
    • Concealed Carry
    • Gun Reviews
    • Gear Reviews
    • Training
    • Firearm Laws & Litigation
    • CCW For Women
    • General Firearm
    • Open Carry
    • Self-Defense
    • Survival
    • Home Defense
  • Forums
  • Podcast
  • Giveaway
  • Store
  • Daily Deals
  • Contact

© 2025 USA Carry LLC

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Concealed Carry Permit Reciprocity Maps
  • Concealed Carry Permit Guides By State
    • Alabama
    • Alaska
    • American Samoa
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • California
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Guam
    • Hawaii
    • Idaho
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Kentucky
    • Louisiana
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Minnesota
    • Mississippi
    • Missouri
    • Montana
    • Nebraska
    • Nevada
    • New Hampshire
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • North Carolina
    • North Dakota
    • Northern Marianas
    • Ohio
    • Oklahoma
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Puerto Rico
    • Rhode Island
    • South Carolina
    • South Dakota
    • Tennessee
    • Texas
    • Utah
    • Vermont
    • Virgin Islands
    • Virginia
    • Washington
    • Washington D.C.
    • West Virginia
    • Wisconsin
    • Wyoming
  • Articles
    • Defensive Gun Uses
    • Concealed Carry
    • Gun Reviews
    • Gear Reviews
    • Training
    • Firearm Laws & Litigation
    • CCW For Women
    • General Firearm
    • Open Carry
    • Self-Defense
    • Survival
    • Home Defense
  • Forums
  • Podcast
  • Giveaway
  • Store
  • Daily Deals
  • Contact

© 2025 USA Carry LLC

wpDiscuz
0
0
Join the conversation, please comment.x
()
x
| Reply
You are going to send email to

Move Comment
Gun Deals
Gun.Deals